April's Articles for Giftware News:
back to articles>>

Striking the Right Balance – Buying and Selling
The Week of September 10, 2007

Sales make the business go 'round. Good sales bring an importer back for another collection from the same factory and a retailer back for another season. Sell-through – particularly full-price sell-through – is something that all parties are striving for. Big sales are the talk of sales meetings at the wholesale level and part of industry brag rights at the manufacturer's level. Meanwhile, at the retail level we call out high sales to each other and reward employees that make them.

But, what happens when a manufacturer and wholesaler oversell and a retailer overbuys?

What happens when multiple companies oversell the retailer? What happens when a company prepacks, and minimums and programs are more than your retailer can handle? What happens when a super salesperson runs your business? Or when the pressure to make sales is so much that salespeople press retailers to take more than they need?

What happens is the retailer does not come back.

What happens is instead of a long-term customer you have a two-season customer, and now you need to get another one.

What happens is your product has become devalued as your customer tries more extreme and outlandish ways to unload the goods.

What happens is the retailer may not be able to pay the bill.

What happens is the reputation of your company becomes industry gossip for pushing unneeded merchandise on a buyer.

With the many changes in the marketplace in recent years, there seem to be two trends at the wholesale level:

1. There are companies who are selling programs such as "fill the fixture" and "buy the assortment" as a style of sales. These orders add up fast, and with a much smaller number of clients you can do significant business. Exclusivity generally becomes an issue, and with that kind of volume, customers expect a territory to themselves. These orders are easy to fill and easy to ship.

2. There are companies that give a fair amount of flexibility in purchasing, taking into account different markets and populations, long-term potential and the shop's ability to repay. These orders tend to be smaller – you need more of them to make your sales goals and people may still argue over exclusivity, though not so convincingly.

Having sat on all sides of this issue – manufacturer, wholesaler and retailer – it is my opinion that short-term gains can cause long-term pains. It is wiser to have the customer under bought than have him crushed under unnecessary inventory. It is wiser for the customer to sell out and be visiting you first next season, than to have a client who won't return your calls and avoids your sales staff. In the end, we need all players alive and healthy to buy another day, sell another season, and become part of our stable customer list.

This formula – the crucial balance of top line sales and customer retention – is what it is all about, and there is a magic in this somewhere. It is creating that balance that is challenging and intriguing, and it says a lot about how we view our own businesses.

Here's to a happy future for the manufacturers, wholesalers, retailers and most importantly – consumers!

April Cornell
Burlington, Vermont

April Cornell Holdings 458 Hurricane Lane, Williston, VT 05495
Phone: 802/897-1271 • Fax: 802/879-7229
©CORNELL TRADING, INC. 2007. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Privacy Policy